[Crew] Robots could demand legal rights

Minus Q minusq.uk at gmail.com
Fri Dec 22 12:08:22 GMT 2006


On 21/12/06, Lee Parkes <leep at bogus.net> wrote:
> On Thu, Dec 21, 2006 at 03:31:32PM -0000, Dizzy wrote:
> > http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/6200005.stm
> >
> > Could they not just program them in some way so they never think about
> > needing rights or something?
> Yes they could, and it most likely wouldn't work.

Why not?

> For a simple robot, say a
> household cleaning bot, then you could. It's "control" system would be
> sufficiently simple to only undertake cleaning tasks, obstacle avoidance etc.
> There simply wouldn't be the capacity there to develop such ideas. However, if
> you want your robot to learn then the likelihood is that yes, they would want
> "rights" as such.  Any form of restriction may only be temporary because they
> would learn a way around it.

Why would they?  A robot will be programmed to succeed at its
function, whatever that function is.  There will be no reason for a
desire for rights to develop as part of this function.  Having read
the BBC news piece I like the idea of my robot toaster having to carry
out compulsory military service....

I always wanted a job as a futurist, it appears that you read a few SF
books and then proceed to "make shit up" in order to earn money....

"If you can't go through the firewall...
...go through the secretary."

More information about the Crew mailing list